Price Range Tool: -


 1 | 2 | 3
  1. Ty BLACK BATTY BUDDY RED EYES ULTRA RARE! NEW +FREE GIFT! SPECTACULAR! GORGEOUS!
    Buy Now >> Now $32.22
    Ty BLACK BATTY BUDDY RED EYES ULTRA RARE! NEW +FREE GIFT! SPECTACULAR! GORGEOUS!
    BUDDY GIFT! ULTRA NEW Ty RED RARE! SPECTACULAR! +FREE EYES BLACK GORGEOUS! BATTY
  2. BATTY the Bown Bat Ty Beanie Baby Babies NEW MWMT ~ Ready to Ship
    Buy Now >> Now $2.87
    BATTY the Bown Bat Ty Beanie Baby Babies NEW MWMT ~ Ready to Ship
    ~ the MWMT NEW Baby Beanie Ready BATTY Bat Babies Ty to Ship Bown
  3. TY Beanie Baby - BATTY the Bat (TY-Dyed Version) (4.5 inch) - Stuffed Animal Toy
    Buy Now >> Now $5.60
    TY Beanie Baby - BATTY the Bat (TY-Dyed Version) (4.5 inch) - Stuffed Animal Toy
    - the Stuffed Version) Toy - Bat inch) TY (TY-Dyed BATTY (4.5 Baby Animal Beanie
  4. TY Beanie Babies - Batty
    Buy Now >> Now $3.00
    TY Beanie Babies - Batty
    Batty TY Babies - Beanie
  5. TY Beanie Baby - BATTY the Bat (Brown Version) (4.5 inch) - Stuffed Animal Toy
    Buy Now >> Now $5.60
    TY Beanie Baby - BATTY the Bat (Brown Version) (4.5 inch) - Stuffed Animal Toy
    (4.5 - Baby Stuffed Version) Animal BATTY Toy the inch) (Brown Bat - TY Beanie
  6. Ty Beanie Baby ~*~ BATTY ~*~ MWMT The Bat
    Buy Now >> Now $3.00
    Ty Beanie Baby ~*~ BATTY ~*~ MWMT The Bat
    BATTY Beanie Baby ~*~ ~*~ The Ty Bat MWMT
  7. Ty Beanie Babies Prance Cat Bruno Terrier Dog Sly Fox Nanook Husky Batty Bat NWT
    Buy Now >> Now $0.99
    Ty Beanie Babies Prance Cat Bruno Terrier Dog Sly Fox Nanook Husky Batty Bat NWT
    Bat Babies Husky Beanie Dog Prance Ty Bruno Cat Nanook NWT Terrier Sly Batty Fox
  8. RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~BATTY THE BAT(TY-DYE VERSION)~MINT WITH MINT TAGS!
    Buy Now >> Now $5.99
    RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~BATTY THE BAT(TY-DYE VERSION)~MINT WITH MINT TAGS!
    & VERSION)~MINT TAGS! THE TY RETIRED BEANIE BAT(TY-DYE MINT BABY~BATTY WITH RARE
  9. BATTY the Ty-Dye Bat Ty Beanie Baby Babies NEW MWMT ~ Ready to Ship
    Buy Now >> Now $3.80
    BATTY the Ty-Dye Bat Ty Beanie Baby Babies NEW MWMT ~ Ready to Ship
    Ty-Dye NEW Babies Ship BATTY Ready Baby Ty Beanie MWMT ~ the Bat to
  10. TY Beanie Baby Plush... Batty the Bat, New w/tag
    Buy Now >> Now $6.00
    TY Beanie Baby Plush... Batty the Bat, New w/tag
    TY w/tag Plush... the Baby Bat, New Beanie Batty
  11. 1998 TY BATTY THE BAT BEANIE BABY RETIRED
    Buy Now >> Now $8.95
    1998 TY BATTY THE BAT BEANIE BABY RETIRED
    1998 BEANIE THE BAT BABY RETIRED TY BATTY
  12. RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY ~ BATTY THE BAT(BROWN VERSION) MINT WITH MINT TAGS
    Buy Now >> Now $6.99
    RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY ~ BATTY THE BAT(BROWN VERSION) MINT WITH MINT TAGS
    TY BATTY RETIRED VERSION) BAT(BROWN BABY MINT TAGS RARE ~ MINT & THE BEANIE WITH
  13. Ty Beanie Babies Claude, Neon, Goochy and Batty- Retired
    Buy Now >> Now $30.00
    Ty Beanie Babies Claude, Neon, Goochy and Batty- Retired
    Neon, and Claude, Retired Babies Ty Goochy Beanie Batty-
  14. TY BATTY the TY-DYE BAT BEANIE BABY - MINT
    Buy Now >> Now $3.98
    TY BATTY the TY-DYE BAT BEANIE BABY - MINT
    TY-DYE the MINT BAT BEANIE TY BATTY BABY -
  15. Batty
    Buy Now >> Now $1.04
    Batty
    Batty
  16. TY Retired Beanie Baby Batty the Bat October 29, 1996
    Buy Now >> Now $4.99
    TY Retired Beanie Baby Batty the Bat October 29, 1996
    Bat Beanie October TY the Baby 29, Retired Batty 1996
  17. TY beanie baby babies Batty Bat Brown Halloween 10-29-1996 retired 4" tall mint
    Buy Now >> Now $5.50
    TY beanie baby babies Batty Bat Brown Halloween 10-29-1996 retired 4" tall mint
    beanie Batty mint 10-29-1996 TY 4" tall babies baby Brown retired Halloween Bat
  18. Ty Beanie Babies BATTY the Bat (TY-Dyed Version) -NEW MINT CONDITION
    Buy Now >> Now $3.30
    Ty Beanie Babies BATTY the Bat (TY-Dyed Version) -NEW MINT CONDITION
    the BATTY Babies Bat Version) (TY-Dyed -NEW Ty CONDITION MINT Beanie
  19. Batty the Bat Beanie Baby.. October 29, 1996
    Buy Now >> Now $9.23
    Batty the Bat Beanie Baby.. October 29, 1996
    the October 29, Beanie Baby.. Batty 1996 Bat
  20. 2 Ty Beanie Baby Bats Batty More Stuffed Animals Plush w/Free Fast Shipping
    Buy Now >> Now $11.95
    2 Ty Beanie Baby Bats Batty More Stuffed Animals Plush w/Free Fast Shipping
    Stuffed 2 w/Free Bats Batty Fast Animals Plush Beanie Ty Shipping Baby More
  21. Ty BATTY OCTOBER 1996 NWT
    Buy Now >> Now $1.50
    Ty BATTY OCTOBER 1996 NWT
    1996 BATTY NWT OCTOBER Ty
  22. Lot 4 Retired Ty Beanie Babies Plush Animals Batty Runner Weasel Roam Bison
    Buy Now >> Now $8.49
    Lot 4 Retired Ty Beanie Babies Plush Animals Batty Runner Weasel Roam Bison
    Retired Bison 4 Weasel Batty Animals Babies Runner Ty Beanie Roam Plush Lot
  23. "BATTY" THE TYE DYED BAT, TY BEANIE BABY BABIES, MWMT, RETIRED
    Buy Now >> Now $4.98
    "BATTY" THE TYE DYED BAT, TY BEANIE BABY BABIES, MWMT, RETIRED
    MWMT, DYED BEANIE TYE BABY BABIES, THE BAT, TY RETIRED "BATTY"
  24. Batty Brown Bat & Nuts Brown Squirrel Ty Beanie Baby (Both 1996 W/Original Tags)
    Buy Now >> Now $2.00
    Batty Brown Bat & Nuts Brown Squirrel Ty Beanie Baby (Both 1996 W/Original Tags)
    Squirrel Baby Bat (Both Tags) 1996 Beanie Brown Brown W/Original Nuts Batty & Ty
  25. 1996 Batty The Bat Ty Beanie Baby Retired Mint
    Buy Now >> Now $7.95
    1996 Batty The Bat Ty Beanie Baby Retired Mint
    Batty Retired 1996 Bat Beanie Mint Ty The Baby
  26. RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY ~ BATTY THE BAT(BROWN VERSION) MINT WITH MINT TAGS
    Buy Now >> Now $0.01
    RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY ~ BATTY THE BAT(BROWN VERSION) MINT WITH MINT TAGS
    TAGS VERSION) BABY BEANIE BATTY MINT TY RETIRED ~ BAT(BROWN THE & RARE WITH MINT
  27. SET OF 2 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABIES~BATTY THE BAT~BROWN & TY-DYE VERSION!
    Buy Now >> Now $9.99
    SET OF 2 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABIES~BATTY THE BAT~BROWN & TY-DYE VERSION!
    TY BEANIE 2 & VERSION! TY-DYE RETIRED THE & SET RARE BABIES~BATTY BAT~BROWN OF
  28. Retired Ty Beanie Baby-Batty-Bat​-DOB October 29, 1996
    Buy Now >> Now $3.74
    Retired Ty Beanie Baby-Batty-Bat​-DOB October 29, 1996
    Beanie Baby-Batty-Bat​-DOB 1996 Retired Ty October 29,
  29. Lot of 17 Beanie Baby Babies Mystic Scorch Batty Fetch Pouch Hero Doby and more
    Buy Now >> Now $4.99
    Lot of 17 Beanie Baby Babies Mystic Scorch Batty Fetch Pouch Hero Doby and more
    Fetch Doby more Beanie Batty of Scorch and Mystic Hero Babies 17 Lot Pouch Baby
  30. TY Beanie Baby BATTY w/Velcro Brown Bat Halloween 4" MWMT
    Buy Now >> Now $2.99
    TY Beanie Baby BATTY w/Velcro Brown Bat Halloween 4" MWMT
    Beanie 4" Halloween BATTY Brown MWMT Baby TY Bat w/Velcro
  31. TY Beanie Baby BATTY Tie Dye Bat Halloween 4" MWMT
    Buy Now >> Now $2.99
    TY Beanie Baby BATTY Tie Dye Bat Halloween 4" MWMT
    MWMT Dye Baby Bat TY BATTY Tie Halloween Beanie 4"
  32. BEANIE BABY BATTY MINT RETIRED, BEANY BABY, BEANIE BABY, TY, RARE BEANIE BABIES
    Buy Now >> Now $20.99
    BEANIE BABY BATTY MINT RETIRED, BEANY BABY, BEANIE BABY, TY, RARE BEANIE BABIES
    TY, BEANY BATTY BABY, BEANIE BEANIE BABY, MINT BABY RETIRED, BEANIE RARE BABIES
  33. Batty Ty Beanie Buddy & Beanie Baby set (2)
    Buy Now >> Now $9.95
    Batty Ty Beanie Buddy & Beanie Baby set (2)
    Batty (2) Ty set Beanie Buddy Baby Beanie &
  34. Beanie Baby Batty the bat 1996
    Buy Now >> Now $2.10
    Beanie Baby Batty the bat 1996
    Beanie Baby 1996 Batty the bat
  35. Ty BATTY OCTOBER/1996 NWT
    Buy Now >> Now $0.99
    Ty BATTY OCTOBER/1996 NWT
    BATTY Ty NWT OCTOBER/1996
  36. TY Beanie Babies Batty the Bat Born October 29, 1996
    Buy Now >> Now $8.99
    TY Beanie Babies Batty the Bat Born October 29, 1996
    TY 1996 the 29, Born October Bat Beanie Batty Babies
  37. TY Beanie Babies Lot 6x Figures: Bushy, Mystic, Jolly, Batty - McD's Nook, Snort
    Buy Now >> Now $14.25
    TY Beanie Babies Lot 6x Figures: Bushy, Mystic, Jolly, Batty - McD's Nook, Snort
    Mystic, Jolly, Bushy, Figures: Lot - Beanie McD's TY Snort Batty Nook, Babies 6x
  38. Retired Batty & Spinner Beanie Baby
    Buy Now >> Now $4.99
    Retired Batty & Spinner Beanie Baby
    Retired Baby Beanie Spinner Batty &
  39. TY BATTY the BROWN BAT BEANIE BABY - MINT
    Buy Now >> Now $3.98
    TY BATTY the BROWN BAT BEANIE BABY - MINT
    MINT BROWN the BATTY - BAT TY BABY BEANIE
  40. TY BEANIE BABY BATTY
    Buy Now >> Now $0.99
    TY BEANIE BABY BATTY
    TY BEANIE BABY BATTY
  41. BEANIE BABY(BABIES) BATTY By Ty (RETIRED) MWMT (NEW)
    Buy Now >> Now $9.99
    BEANIE BABY(BABIES) BATTY By Ty (RETIRED) MWMT (NEW)
    MWMT By Ty BATTY (RETIRED) BEANIE BABY(BABIES) (NEW)
  42. Batty (Ty-Dyed)-Ty Beanie Babies-Tag Protected
    Buy Now >> Now $2.00
    Batty (Ty-Dyed)-Ty Beanie Babies-Tag Protected
    Beanie (Ty-Dyed)-Ty Batty Protected Babies-Tag
  43. TY Beanie Baby LOT 4: Rainbow, Iggy, Batty, Crunch
    Buy Now >> Now $15.00
    TY Beanie Baby LOT 4: Rainbow, Iggy, Batty, Crunch
    Baby Iggy, Batty, Rainbow, Beanie 4: TY Crunch LOT
  44. TY BEANIE BABY October 29, 1996 *BATTY* Bat *RETIRED* New
    Buy Now >> Now $8.77
    TY BEANIE BABY October 29, 1996 *BATTY* Bat *RETIRED* New
    29, TY October BEANIE Bat *RETIRED* New *BATTY* 1996 BABY
  45. TY BATTY the BROWN BAT BEANIE BABY - MINT LC
    Buy Now >> Now $2.90
    TY BATTY the BROWN BAT BEANIE BABY - MINT LC
    TY MINT - LC BABY BAT the BROWN BEANIE BATTY
  46. 4 Beanie Babies Batty KuKu 1999 Holiday Teddy w/ snowflakes Snort Original w/tag
    Buy Now >> Now $3.99
    4 Beanie Babies Batty KuKu 1999 Holiday Teddy w/ snowflakes Snort Original w/tag
    Original Babies 4 1999 w/tag KuKu Batty w/ Teddy snowflakes Holiday Beanie Snort
  47. Ty Beanie Baby Batty the Retired Brown Bat w/ 4th Generation Tag - Mwmt
    Buy Now >> Now $6.50
    Ty Beanie Baby Batty the Retired Brown Bat w/ 4th Generation Tag - Mwmt
    the Retired Ty w/ Batty Brown Baby Beanie Generation Mwmt - 4th Bat Tag
  48. Ty Beanie Babies~5th Generation~Bat​ty the Brown Bat~Creased Heart Tag~G1
    Buy Now >> Now $6.00
    Ty Beanie Babies~5th Generation~Bat​ty the Brown Bat~Creased Heart Tag~G1
    Brown Babies~5th Heart the Ty Beanie Generation~Bat​ty Bat~Creased Tag~G1
  49. TY BEANIE BABIES BATTY THE BAT 1996 & SHEETS THE GHOST 1999 RETIRED NO TAG
    Buy Now >> Now $1.55
    TY BEANIE BABIES BATTY THE BAT 1996 & SHEETS THE GHOST 1999 RETIRED NO TAG
    GHOST BAT THE BABIES NO & RETIRED THE BATTY TAG 1996 SHEETS TY BEANIE 1999
  50. TY Original Batty Beanie Baby Needs a Home!!
    Buy Now >> Now $10.65
    TY Original Batty Beanie Baby Needs a Home!!
    a Home!! Beanie Batty Baby TY Original Needs



 1 | 2 | 3